Graphic Media Alliance

Complete Story
 

06/11/2025

Workplace Discrimination

Source: Fisher Phillips, June 5, 2025

SCOTUS Scraps Extra Hurdle in Majority-Group Bias Claims: 5 Ways That Things Will Change for Employers

The US Supreme Court just unanimously ruled that plaintiffs alleging workplace discrimination under Title VII are not required to meet a heightened evidentiary standard just because they have “majority-group” status. Today’s landmark decision in Ames v. Ohio Department of Youth Services eliminates the additional requirements previously imposed by several federal appellate courts that made it harder for majority-group plaintiffs, such as heterosexual or White workers, to prove discrimination. This significant decision, which does away with extra steps for so-called “reverse” discrimination claims, will most likely result in an increase in workplace bias claims in many parts of the country. What are the five ways that things will change in this new era of discrimination litigation?

Allegations in a Nutshell

  • Marlean Ames, a heterosexual woman, was employed for roughly 15 years by the Ohio Department of Youth Services (DYS), the state’s juvenile corrections system.
  • In 2019, Ames applied for a promotion, but DYS instead hired a gay woman for the role.
  • DYS also demoted her and reduced her wages by nearly $20 per hour, replacing her with a gay man.
  • Both of these decisions were made by heterosexual individuals.
  • After filing a discrimination charge with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Ames filed a Title VII lawsuit against the Ohio DYS, alleging discrimination based on sexual orientation.

What Do You Need to Know About Title VII?

  • You probably already know that Title VII bars discrimination against workers because of race, color, religion, national origin, and sex. The Supreme Court’s 2020 decision in Bostock v. Clayton County held that “because of . . . sex” includes discrimination based on an individual’s sexual orientation or gender identity.
  • Typically, workers only need to show the following four steps to advance the ball in a Title VII claim: (1) they are a member of a protected class, (2) they were subject to an adverse employment decision, (3) they were qualified for the relevant position, and (4) their employer treated more favorably a similarly qualified person who was not a member of the same protected class.
  • But some federal appellate courts (the 6th, 7th, 8th, 10th, and D.C. Circuits) required majority-group plaintiffs – those advancing what some call “reverse” discrimination claims – to jump over an additional hurdle. In those circuits, such plaintiffs must also show “background circumstances to support the suspicion that the defendant is that unusual employer who discriminates against the majority.”

SCOTUS Scraps Additional Hurdle, Opens Door for More Litigation ...

How’d We Do With Our Predictions? ...

Implications for Employers ...

Read full article

Printer-Friendly Version



2025 Wage + Benefits Survey

We're now just one day away from the August 1 deadline. Don’t ignore reality by assuming you’ve already outpaced the competition. While you’re standing still, others could be soaring ahead—attracting top talent and leaving you behind.

Read More

PEA Grand Ceremony

Please join us in congratulating the Best of Category winners! These prestigious awards, along with Judge’s Awards, Rising Star and Best of Show will be recognized at the Grand Ceremony on August 21.

Read More

The Inside Scoop on M&A in the Printing Industry

Graphic Media Alliance is proud to host a special in-person Executive Leadership Training Session featuring Jim Russell of New Direction Partners covering critical insights on the 2025 Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A) landscape.

Read More

"America's AI Action Plan" Promises Big Changes Across Industries

America’s AI Action Plan will have a huge impact not only AI developers and the tech sector but also on many employers and employees throughout the US workforce.

Read More

Project Management and the Mailpiece Design Consultant Workshops

GMA's sister association, Print & Graphic Communications Association, is hosting two workshops. In August, learn how to master the art of project management in accordance with the Project Management Body of Knowledge. Then, in October, become familiar with and test the US Postal information contained in the MSMA MDC Study Guide.

Read More

One Less Thing

AI offers some amazing capabilities, but because it takes time to learn and master each agent, you might want to take the advice Bill Farquharson shares in this week's Short Attention Span Sales Tip before going down every AI rabbit hole.

Read More